Western Meddling & The Cycle of Failure in the Middle East
From Iran to Syria: why western meddling often makes conflicts worse.
Alexandra Audrey Tompson
Dec 23, 2024 - 1:29 PM
The History of Western Overreach
Western intervention in the Middle East has often backfired, fueling chaos instead of delivering stability, democracy, or peace. History is packed with examples of foreign powers making bad situations worse. Activist Loay Alshareef breaks down this cycle of failure, showing how meddling repeatedly leads to conflict and unintended fallout. He calls for a hard look at past mistakes to rethink the future of Western involvement in the region.
The 1953 Iranian Coup
In 1953, the CIA and MI6 orchestrated the ousting of Iran’s Prime Minister, Muhammad Mossadegh, after he moved to nationalize the oil industry. They replaced him with Shah Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, turning him into a Western-backed autocrat. This intervention fueled resentment, laying the groundwork for the 1979 Islamic Revolution and decades of instability and anti-Western sentiment that still echo in Iranian politics.
Egypt: Cold War Missteps
In the 1950s, the U.S. backed Egypt’s Gamal Abdel Nasser to counter Soviet influence in the Middle East. But when Nasser leaned toward the USSR, American support vanished. This flip-flopping deepened regional instability and fractured Arab unity, fueling rivalries that still resonate today. Egypt’s case exposes a major flaw in Western interventions: chasing short-term political goals at the expense of the region’s long-term stability.
Lebanon’s Civil War
During Lebanon’s Civil War (1975–1990), U.S. and French attempts to stabilize the country backfired. Rather than easing tensions, their involvement worsened the sectarian divide and prolonged the violence. This failure highlights a recurring problem with Western interventions: a lack of understanding of the region’s complex political and cultural dynamics.
Somalia: “Black Hawk Down” Debacle
The 1990s U.S. and UN mission in Somalia aimed to tackle famine and local power struggles but spiraled into chaos. The “Black Hawk Down” incident, where American soldiers were killed in Mogadishu, revealed the stark limits of Western power in a region fractured by deep internal divisions.
Iraq Invasion
The 2003 U.S. invasion of Iraq is a textbook case of intervention gone wrong. Justified by false claims of weapons of mass destruction (WMDs), the invasion dismantled Iraq’s institutions, plunging the country into chaos. The resulting power vacuum fueled sectarian violence and enabled the rise of extremist groups like ISIS, leaving a legacy of instability that persists to this day.
Yemen, Libya, and Syria: A Trilogy of Failure
In Yemen, Western backing of the Saudi-led coalition worsened the humanitarian crisis and heightened regional tensions. NATO’s 2011 intervention in Libya, meant to oust Muammar Gaddafi, resulted in the state’s collapse and years of chaos. In Syria, Western support for anti-Assad rebels fueled the civil war and gave extremists a foothold.
Afghanistan: A Failed Mission
Afghanistan is a stark example of Western intervention gone awry. The U.S. entered to fight Al-Qaeda and oust the Taliban, but the mission morphed into a costly, two-decade-long nation-building effort. Despite vast investments, the Taliban regained control in 2021, and the chaotic withdrawal of U.S. troops revealed the failure of the entire operation.
The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict
Western attempts to mediate the Israeli-Palestinian conflict have often been criticized for favoring Israeli interests and neglecting Palestinian grievances. These efforts have failed to address the core issues, leaving the region unstable and stuck in a cycle of violence and frustration. The imbalance in diplomacy continues to fuel tensions, blocking any real path to peace.
Rethinking Western Intervention
The lesson from these failed interventions is undeniable: Western powers need to change their approach to the Middle East. Rather than imposing external solutions that often worsen the situation, the West should prioritize diplomatic engagement and respect for regional sovereignty. Supporting grassroots peace efforts and honoring local governance could help break the destructive cycle of intervention that has long plagued the region.
Alexandra Audrey Tompson
Editor-in-Chief | Lawyer (Admitted in New York; England & Wales)
